Recruiters share their favorite questions to ask in job interviews — and how candidates should answer them

Recruiters told BI what their go-to interview questions can reveal about a job candidate.

SB/Getty Images

One of the biggest parts of preparing for a job interview is running through practice questions.We asked recruiting pros for their top interview questions and how a candidate should answer them.Here’s what they told us.

When you’re preparing for a job interview, one of the first things you can do is research what previous candidates have shared about their own interviews with that employer. Some of the most helpful information to glean, if you can find it, is what interview questions you might expect to be asked.

To help job seekers who might not be able to find common questions asked by a specific company, we asked five recruiting professionals for their favorite questions to ask in job interviews.

They also broke down how candidates should answer and what the answers can reveal about them. Of course, the slate of questions asked in an interview can vary based on the recruiter’s personal preferences, the role, and other factors — but these go-to questions from recruiters are a good place to start.

Here’s a look at questions recruiters love to ask that they say can be particularly telling about a candidate.

‘Tell me a time when you found a way to improve a process, made something more efficient, or otherwise introduced an improvement when you weren’t asked to do so.’

Kyle Samuels, who spent 20 years in senior-level executive recruiting and is now CEO of executive search agency Creative Talent Endeavors, said he likes this question because it helps identify “proactive leaders who are willing to answer difficult questions and drive business results.”

He recommends candidates use the STAR method — focusing on the situation, task, action, and result — to answer this question and really highlight their “initiative and drive.”

“I’m also looking for candidates who can stand up to additional questioning well and describe specifics within each example or story they share when responding,” he said.

He shared with us one example of how a STAR-formatted answer to this question might look:

Situation: “Our SaaS solution isn’t cutting it.”Task: “I was assigned to fix the problem.”Action: “I spoke to other CTOs to get recommendations, found a final list of five, and then evaluated them against the incumbent so we could make the right hiring decision.”Result: Explain the end result and what happened after taking the actions described.

‘Tell me about a time when something went terribly wrong with a project.’

This question shows a candidate’s “ability to take responsibility for mistakes, solve problems, communicate effectively, and collaborate with others,” said Lauren Monroe, who leads the creative practice group at Aquent, a staffing agency for creative, marketing, and design roles.

An ideal answer would “name the specific challenge faced, acknowledge the mistakes made, and identify the actions taken, lessons learned, and solutions implemented to solve the problem,” she added.

‘What key elements need to be in your next role, and what would be a dealbreaker for you?’

Amri Celeste, a recruitment manager and interview coach, likes this question because it gets at “what a candidate is really looking for in a role and whether the role we’re discussing matches what they expect in their next role.”

“It’s also an opportunity to open up a more honest dialogue about their values, work style, and career goals, which helps me learn about not only how well they suit the role, but also how well they might suit the team and management style of the manager,” she said.

‘Tell me about yourself.’

It’s a tried-and-true interview question, and Andrew Fennell, a former corporate recruiter and the founder of the résumé-builder website StandOut CV, leans on it to set the tone in interviews.

“After introducing myself and explaining how I’ve arrived to the point of this interview, I ask the candidate to do the same,” he said.

“It relaxes the atmosphere a bit, makes it a bit more conversational, and allows the candidate to give a well-rounded summary of their experience and skills,” he added.

‘Tell me about the greatest impact you made at a company and what helped you achieve that impact.’

Tessa White, a former head of HR, is the CEO of The Job Doctor and the author of “The Unspoken Truths for Career Success.”

Besides asking about a candidate’s achievements, White also tries to gauge their ability to problem-solve by asking questions about challenges they’ve encountered in the past.

She’ll ask, for example, “Tell me about a time you were at odds with someone or a department and you were able to successfully move through it.”

Other times, she might say, “Tell me about a time when an initiative or project you were leading wasn’t going the way you hoped. How did you handle it and what is your philosophy for addressing obstacles?”

For all of these questions, she said the ideal answer should be “authentic and real.” If it’s not, a recruiter can “sniff it a mile away,” she said.

“I’m not looking for the answer you think I want to hear,” she said. “I’m looking to see an imperfect person that has insight into their strengths as well as someone who understands how to learn from previous mistakes.”