I made Ina Garten’s 5-cheese penne pasta and it was the comfort dish of my dreams

To whip up her five-cheese penne, you’ll need: 

1/2 cup freshly grated pecorino Romano 1/2 cup shredded Italian fontina 1/4 cup crumbled Italian Gorgonzola 1/4 pound fresh mozzarella, sliced2 tablespoons ricotta cheese

I should admit that I got Romano cheese instead of pecorino Romano, which I couldn’t find in my local supermarket’s little fromagerie no matter how hard I tried. I did a quick Google search — “Is pecorino the same as Romano?” — and was convinced that they were basically identical. I later learned that the Romano I had purchased was actually made with cow’s milk, while pecorino Romano is always made with sheep’s milk.

But alas, they’re both still in the same family and known for their sharp flavors, so I think the cheese gods will forgive me on this one. 

On top of all that cheese, you’ll need: 

1 pound penne rigate pasta2 cups heavy cream1 cup crushed tomatoes in thick tomato puree6 fresh basil leaves, chopped

This is the only part of Garten’s recipe that actually requires a little work.

I hadn’t bought pre-shredded fontina or pre-crumbled Gorgonzola, so I decided to just grate them as well. And let me tell you, it was definitely an arm workout. Next time, I’ll likely just finely chop the fontina instead, as its creamy texture made it a tad trickier to work with the grater. 

From the creamy ricotta to the sharp Romano, I was excited to see how all these different flavors and textures would blend together. 

I also chopped up some basil to throw on top.

Per Garten’s recipe, you’re not actually supposed to fully cook the pasta. You just need to parboil the penne for four minutes in a pot of salted water. 

After I dumped my pound of pasta into the pot, I set a timer and went back to my bowl of cheese. 

Who knew Garten’s pasta would be so on-trend? The color was actually quite pretty, and not at all what I had expected. 

Garten recommends dividing your pasta into “shallow ceramic gratin dishes.” I don’t even own a proper stove pot, much less pretty cookware! But I realized that this dish could easily turn into a one-pot recipe, and who doesn’t love dealing with fewer dishes?

So, I tossed the penne with the mixture, making sure all the noodles were submerged in the pretty pink pool of cheese.  

As much as I love Garten, I have to admit that I went against her recipe on this last step. The “Barefoot Contessa” star recommends using half a stick (four tablespoons) of unsalted butter to dot your penne pasta with, which sounded very overwhelming, to be honest. 

My friend Molly, who is far more experienced in the kitchen than I am, confirmed that half a stick of butter would be too much — especially paired with all that cheese. So, I decided to take the recipe down to just one tablespoon, using a knife to shave off little knobs of butter that I sprinkled right on top of the pot.

Garten’s recipe recommends cooking the pasta until it’s “bubbly and brown” on top, which she estimates will take around seven to 10 minutes.

As I waited for the pasta to cook, the delicious smell of cheese completely filled the kitchen. And, as the minutes ticked by, I could hear the penne start to bubble.

Of course, every oven is different. Overall, it took my pasta about 17 minutes total to bake. I waited until I could see that the penne in the center of my pan was turning brown before I took it out, ensuring it had cooked through.

The millennial pink turned into a beautiful almost golden color, and there appeared to be an even crust on the top of the pasta. 

The chunks of mozzarella that had floated to the top made the dish look even more inviting. I already felt soothed.

As much as I love very saucy pastas, I did wonder if five different cheeses — plus plenty of butter and cream — would be too much. I worried that the dish might taste more like cheese with a side of pasta, rather than the other way around, but my fears were unfounded. Garten’s penne manages to be rich and soothing, without feeling too heavy on the stomach. 

“All that cheese,” my friend Molly happily exclaimed as she took her first few bites. “It tastes like a warm blanket.” 

“But the cheese isn’t overwhelming,” added my friend Joe, who was also on taste-test duty. 

Molly recommended sprinkling some red pepper flakes on top to cut the pasta’s richness just a bit, which ended up being a great addition. And I loved the contrast between the crusty pieces and the gooey cheeses, which had sunk inside the penne and would burst with every bite.

Garten’s five-cheese penne has the power of a warm blanket, roaring fireplace, and mug of hot coca — all wrapped up in one cheesy bowl.